I hopped on over to CNet this evening where I saw this video shot at Tech Fest 2008 in Redmond WA. It looks as though Microsoft is doing some development work on some next generation photo editing tools. One of these tools allows you to insert people/objects into pictures that weren’t in the original shot. Now, this is not news to anybody who is a Photoshop guru as you can do this accurately in Photoshop or most other photo editing software packages. However, it seems to me that to do something like this in Photoshop is much more involved and tedious than what I saw in the video.
When inserting people and objects into photos, using a set horizon line (determined by the user), the program automatically determines the correct size of the object so that linear perspective is left intact. It also accurately places applicable shadows below the object given the light source direction in the photo.
Another technology demonstrated in this video is used for recovering blown out highlights from photos with similar areas in the photo which are correctly exposed. You can again do a similar thing in Photoshop, but again probably involves 10 times more steps than what is shown in the video to accomplish such effects.
The real question I have is, does software like this make the meaning of photography (think “painting with light”) go away? The fact that you have to get the picture right in the camera anymore is becoming less and less important as technology like this is developed. Don’t get me wrong, I think there are people out there that like this kind of digital art just as there are those who love HDR images and those that still only shoot film (believe it or not there are some people still shooting film out there).
I have been thinking lately how proud I am of the few shots which have just required some minor “global” adjustments to the image just as I would do in a dark room when developing film and making prints. I have been using Aperture 2.0 for my global image adjustments and I am loving it. I have yet to become a Photoshop expert but that doesn’t mean I won’t someday get into it and use it regularly, as I think it is a great piece of software. I am just wondering if photographers still care that the photos come out great right out of the camera rather than just clicking the shutter and thinking “I can fix this later in Photoshop”.
Bottom line, I ponder about this as I grow in my photography hobby, but it is good to know that I am in a hobby that has so many “genres” to explore, I love it!